Questions on Mutilate

[Vicarious]

What would you guys say scales best for Mutilate damage in PvP between attack power and agility? I've tried both and I can't really decide myself and I'm not educated enough in rogue play to really know which is better for most situations. Most say that AP is the best way to go but I find the extra crit from agility can never hurt (plus dodge is kinda helpful). Also I don't really understand the argument as to why people believe AP is the only option for Mutilate, you only have one guaranteed crit from Cold Blood and I find that I don't crit very often otherwise if I'm stacking AP instead of agility.

[Apuclevercow]

We can't really answer about this oooold question.
Some guys were saying that agility is better than ap by far because you also get crits and dodge, moreover with bok, you'll get a 10% agility bonus.
But, on a 10 agility gem, you'll just win 1 agility, which is still less than what gives a 20 ap gem.

It depends on the way you want to play muti : with a healer, with a dps, alone on BGs, on duels, on instances, etc...

[Cube]

Seal Fate makes agility better. If you don't crit, you won't build any cp's. You have to build your crit rating to get the most out of your energy.